Asphalt Batch Plants
On July 20, 2020 the City Council unanimously adopted performance standards for asphalt batch plants in zones where it was already allowed. Now, it is a conditional use, instead of an outright permitted use, in the M-2 to offer additional protections. The Council also unanimously rejected a proposal to add asphalt batching to the General Commercial zone. The final ordinance is available in the Document Library. This decision followed months of public comments and council discussion and a recommendation by the Sumner Planning Commission. The approval, however, maintains a prohibition on asphalt batch facilities in the East Sumner General Commercial zoning where the Corliss Resources main concrete batch facility is located.
The Interim Development Regulations (IDR) were adopted last August by the City Council that temporarily prohibit future expansion of existing facilities or the addition of new facilities. This allowed staff and the State Department of Health to study potential health impacts of asphalt batching facilities. The IDR was extended for 6 months in January and expired on July 20.
On July 20, 2020 the City Council unanimously adopted performance standards for asphalt batch plants in zones where it was already allowed. Now, it is a conditional use, instead of an outright permitted use, in the M-2 to offer additional protections. The Council also unanimously rejected a proposal to add asphalt batching to the General Commercial zone. The final ordinance is available in the Document Library. This decision followed months of public comments and council discussion and a recommendation by the Sumner Planning Commission. The approval, however, maintains a prohibition on asphalt batch facilities in the East Sumner General Commercial zoning where the Corliss Resources main concrete batch facility is located.
The Interim Development Regulations (IDR) were adopted last August by the City Council that temporarily prohibit future expansion of existing facilities or the addition of new facilities. This allowed staff and the State Department of Health to study potential health impacts of asphalt batching facilities. The IDR was extended for 6 months in January and expired on July 20.
Q&A
Do you have any general comments or questions about this topic in general? Ask here and we will respond soon. Please note that because this process is about studying this topic, we may not have a response until the actual assessments return.
-
Is this where you would like to receive citizen comments in regards to the asphalt plant building built? I know that Ryan had stated it would be open to the public till March 18th. Would like to make sure that the Sumner City Planner Committee has read these comments as well. Thank you,
Laurenleigh asked over 4 years agoYes, the City is accepting comments until 5PM March 18. Please submit comments to Ryan Windish, Community Development Director; email: ryanw@sumnerwa.gov or drop-off or US Mail to:
Ryan Windish, Sumner City Hall, 1104 Maple Street, Sumner, WA 98390
-
I was unable to attend the 2/10/2020 study session. Will you please let us know how to view a video of it, or obtain the meeting minutes so the citizens who could not attend know what was discussed? Thank you.
SumnerResident asked almost 5 years agoI posted the audio from the 2/10/2020 City Council Study Session in the Document Library. I apologize for this taking so long, but we don't often get requests for audio and we were seeing if we could adjust the quality of the recording, it is a little hard to hear.
-
Since you passed the new zoning for Corliss, does that mean they can use accessory as an asphalt plant? So the studies you are currently doing are all for not and it’s a done deal? When will the citizens of Sumner get an update on those studies?
Linda Till asked about 5 years agoWhen the Council passed zoning amendments, they also passed an Interim Development Regulation which prohibits any new asphalt batch plants until the studies are completed and Council has had time to contemplate the facts and data that will be provided. The Health Impact Assessment (HIA) will be completed in December. All reports will be available to the public for review and comment in this forum and at open public meetings and a public hearing. Please take a look at the schedule on this website and follow us for updates.
-
What has the city done to protect the citizens around the current asphalt plant? How has the city managed to ensure that asphalt plant is filling all EP A rules? Where can I find what the city is doing to ensure the citizens are safe from the current plant?
Linda Till asked about 5 years agoThe Puget Sound Clean Air Agency ensures we have clean air to breath in the region. They play a significant part in permitting and monitoring such uses. You can contact them at 206-343-8800 and they'll be able to provide you copies of monitoring reports and data of the plant. To date the City of Sumner hasn't received any complaints for this facility.
Additionally, in 2002, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) deleted asphalt concrete manufacturing (batch plant) as a source category because “available data indicate that there are no major sources in any of the source categories” (Federal Register, Vol. 67, No. 29, p. 6521).
-
How is the city going to protect the 3 mile radius of a new asphalt batch plant when the following is within that Radius? 3 mile radius summary: Dieringer well City Water Aquifer Residential housing, commercial Businesses and farmland Lake Tapps 2 rivers - Puyallup and White River 3 Senior Care facilities 7 Towns counting Sumner 2 mile radius: Central Well City Water Aquifer Residential housing, commercial Businesses and Farmland 3 lakes, Lake Tapps, Bonney Lake, Debra Jane Lake 2 rivers Puyallup and White river 13 schools 9 Parks 2 senior care facilities 2 towns Bonney Lake and Sumner 1 mile radius: County Springs City Water Aquifer Elhi Springs City Water Aquifer South Well City Water Aquifer Sumner Springs City Water Aquifer Weber Springs City Water Aquifer A total of 5 of our seven city water Supplies are within a 1 mile radius! Residential housing, commercial Businesses and Farmland Puyallup River Salmon Creek, Salmon Springs 1 School 3 Parks YMCA 5 Senior Care Facilities 2 towns Sumner and Bonney Lake In conclusion, if you don't get a handle on this catastrophe problem that is waiting to happen, we will all suffer not only with our health, but our water supplies, food that we eat, rivers, lakes, springs and stream pollution and our property devaluation all for Corliss Corporate profits! I think the citizens of Sumner and our surrounding towns deserve better than that. Please vote “NO” for Corliss asphalt plant in Sumner. Thank you
Linda Till asked about 5 years agoThe City has partnered with the State Department of Health, who will provide us a Health Impact Assessment for asphalt batch plants in general. This study will provide facts and data to help the City Council make an educated decision about future zoning allowances throughout the city. This report will be available to the public in December. Please keep in mind the City Council only has jurisdiction over areas within our city limits. Pierce County’s zones already allow for asphalt batch plants as a conditional use.
Document Library
- Ordinance No. 2737_FINAL.pdf (769 KB) (pdf)
- Map of Ord. 2737 Results.pdf (1.28 MB) (pdf)
- 20200622_Staff_Report_City_Council_SS (3.11 MB) (pdf)
- 20200604_PC_AGENDA_PACKET.pdf (2.69 MB) (pdf)
- 20200319_PC_AGENDA_PACKET (1.26 MB) (pdf)
- SEPA Determination of Non-significance (75.9 KB) (pdf)
- 20200305_PC_AGENDA_PACKET (973 KB) (pdf)
- Asphalt Health Impact Assessment (2.42 MB) (pdf)
FAQ
- What prompted you to realize there was a zoning code issue for the existing concrete batching faciity?
- Has the original zoning issue totally been resolved, and now could an asphalt batching plant be added as an accessory use?
- What are the next steps in an IDR process?
- Is it even within the city council's power to stop a potential asphalt plant?
Life Cycle
-
August 5, 2019 - Council Approves IDR
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council approved Ordinance 2704, authorizing the Interim Development Regulations. Click here to watch that meeting online.
-
September 9 - Study Session
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council discusses the kind of report it will seek on asphalt batch plants and from whom. There is no public comment period at a study session.
-
September 16 - Public Hearing on Setting the IDR
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageAt the City Council meeting, the Council will take public comments on the City setting this interim development regulation. This is a hearing about the process itself. Each speaker will have three minutes. You also have the option to submit a written comment on this site in the Comments area. That option remains open through Friday, September 20 at 5 pm. Click here to watch the meeting online.
-
October 7 - Adoption of Findings of Fact
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council formally adopts Findings of Fact for enacting the Interim Development Regulation from testimony provided during the previous Public Hearing. Click here to watch the meeting online.
-
November - Reporting Drafting Work
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageHealth Impact Assessment, traffic study and real estate assessment reporting work.
-
December 16 - Council Meeting
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stagePublic Hearing about extending the IDR. This is a hearing about the process itself. Each speaker will have three minutes.
-
January 13 - City Council Study Session
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council discusses extending the Interim Development Regulations and findings of fact on the process of extending only.
-
January 21, 2020 - City Council Meeting
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageOrdinance before the City Council on whether or not to extend the Interim Development Regulations. There will be no public comment since the public hearing on this was held December 16.
-
February 6, 2020 - Planning Commission
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stagePlanning Commission review reports from expert consultants including health impact assessment, traffic and real estate impacts. Reports will also be available on this site for online review.
-
February 7 - Notice of Application for Environmental Review and Comment
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stagePublic notice goes out on environmental review process with a comment deadline of Feb 21. specifying date and time of public hearing regarding the reports received. Notice can be found on the City website here: https://sumnerwa.gov/notice-of-application-sumner-zoning-code-text-amendment-asphalt-plants/
-
February 10, 2020 - City Council Study Session
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageReview of reports from expert consultants including health impact, traffic and real estate impacts. Reports will also be available on this site for online review.
-
February 20, 2020 - Planning Commission
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stagePlanning Commission discusses the reports received including health impact, traffic and real estate impact reports. If needed.
-
March 5, 2020 - Planning Commission Public Hearing
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe Planning Commission holds a Public Hearing to hear people's thoughts and reactions to any proposed zoning code changes regarding asphalt batch plants. Speakers will have three minutes each. There will also be an extended period for people to comment on this site. Watch for details about deadlines. The Planning Commission agenda packet can be found here: https://sumner.civicweb.net/filepro/documents/21595?preview=21662
TIP: It is not necessary to comment online and in person--all comments received before the deadline become part of the record.
-
March 18, 2020 - Deadline for Public Hearing Extended Comment Period
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe Planning Commission will hold a public hearing on March 5 (see above) to receive public comments, however, written comments will be accepted until 5PM on March 18, 2020. Comments can be submitted to: Ryan Windish, Community Development Director email: ryanw@sumnerwa.gov or mailed or dropped off at: City Hall, 1104 Maple Street, Sumner, WA 98390.
-
March 19, 2020-Planning Commission Special Meeting-CANCELED
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe Planning Commission meeting has been CANCELED due to the COVID-19 outbreak. We are still receiving written comments through March 18th. At this time, we do not have a future date for the meeting but will post to Sumner Connects when we know. Thank you for your patience during these unprecedented times. The Agenda Packet is available here: https://sumner.civicweb.net/filepro/documents/21595?preview=21697
-
June 4, 2020 - Planning Commission Meeting
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe Planning Commission will vote on a recommendation to the City Council regarding the zoning code amendments for asphalt batch plants.
-
June 22, 2020 - City Council Study Session
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council reviews and discusses the Planning Commission's recommendations for zoning code amendments regarding asphalt batch plants. (Note: On June 4th the Planning Commission voted 3-2 in favor of a recommendation that the City Council approve the proposed ordinance.)
-
July 6, 2020 - City Council Meeting
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council votes on any proposed changes, or amendments, to zoning code regarding asphalt batch plants.
-
July 8, 2020 - City Council Special Meeting
Asphalt Batch Plants has finished this stageThe City Council voted 5-2 on July 6 to postpone indefinitely action on the ordinance that would allow asphalt batch plants in Sumner. This Special Meeting is to discuss options for the Interim Development Regulations that expire on July 20.
-
July 13, 2020 - City Council Study Session
Asphalt Batch Plants is currently at this stageThe City Council will discuss amendments and alternatives to Ordinance No. 2737 presented last Monday night.
-
July 20, 2020 - Council Meeting- Final Action
this is an upcoming stage for Asphalt Batch PlantsThe City Council votes on any proposed changes, or amendments, to zoning code regarding asphalt batch plants.
Who's listening
-
Phone 253-299-5524 Email ryanw@sumnerwa.gov